Planning guideTax Planning

Should I do a Roth conversion? A real example, from the model to the estate plan

Nyle Bayer, CEO of Up Capital ManagementNyle Bayer, AIF®, ARPCCEO · Published · 12 min read
LinkedInEmail

Paying tax on your retirement savings years before the IRS makes you can feel backwards. For one couple, our hypothetical projection showed it could leave their kids about $3.4 million more. A Roth conversion may make sense when the tax you pay now is lower than the tax you, your spouse or your kids would pay later.

This fall we worked through that exact question with a couple I’ll call Mark and Elena. Most of their savings were in pre-tax accounts, a big piece of their net worth was one company’s stock, and their goal was clear, to leave as much as they could to their children and the causes they care about. Their question was simple. If we pay tax now so our kids pay less later, do the kids end up with more or less?

This post walks through how we answered it, from the model to the estate plan. Their names and personal details are changed and generalized so they can’t be identified, and every result is a hypothetical projection, not an actual result.

What’s interesting about this situation is that it actually started as an estate planning conversation, where we needed to put their estate plan docs in place with a lot of thought about what they were going to leave behind, the impact and the legacy they wanted. From there, it turned into, “If we want to leave as much as possible to our kids, how do we do it in the most tax-efficient way?” That’s what started the Roth conversion discussion in the first place, thinking long term.

Why does a Roth strategy matter?

A Roth strategy decides when you pay tax on your retirement savings, and at what rate. Money in a traditional IRA or 401(k) has never been taxed, so every dollar that comes out later is taxed as ordinary income by the federal government and by California.

Three things tend to push that bill up if nothing is done.

  • For anyone born in 1960 or later, the IRS requires yearly withdrawals from pre-tax accounts starting at 75, called required minimum distributions (RMDs). Roth IRAs have no required withdrawals during the owner’s lifetime.
  • After one spouse dies, the other generally files as a single taxpayer starting the year after, unless a dependent child qualifies them for surviving spouse status. For 2026, the 22% federal bracket ends at $211,400 of taxable income for a married couple and at $105,700 for a single filer, so the same withdrawals can land in a higher bracket for the survivor.
  • Most adult children who inherit an IRA must empty it within 10 years. A traditional IRA hands them that tax bill, often during their own peak earning years. An inherited Roth has the same 10-year deadline, and qualified withdrawals from it are generally income tax-free.

A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA into a Roth IRA. You pay income tax on the amount converted that year, and qualified withdrawals after that are tax-free. The years between retirement and the start of RMDs are usually when income is lowest, which is when converting tends to cost the least.

Who are Mark and Elena?

Mark is in his early 60s and retired after a long corporate career. Elena is in her late 50s and plans to stop working soon. They live in Northern California, Social Security is still a few years off for both of them, and Elena has a modest pension.

What they ownRoughly
Traditional IRAs and workplace retirement plansClose to $2 million
Roth IRAsA small balance
Taxable investment accountsA little over $2 million
Stock in one company, inside the taxable accountsA six-figure position with a large built-in gain

Their biggest long-term goal was passing as much as possible to their children and the causes they care about.

How did we model it?

We built two versions of their future side by side, one where they convert and one where they don’t, and ran both year by year to their life expectancy.

The conversion plan moves enough from their traditional IRAs each year to fill the 22% federal bracket, from now through age 75. A bracket is the slice of income taxed at one rate. In the years Medicare uses to set premiums, each conversion also stops just under the first tier of the Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA), a Medicare surcharge based on your tax return from two years earlier. For 2026, that first tier starts above $218,000 of income for a married couple, using a version of income the IRS calls modified adjusted gross income.

  • About $1.9 million converted over 14 years, Mark’s IRA first and Elena’s after
  • About $520,000 of federal and California tax on those conversions in the dollars of each year, an average rate near 27%
  • The company stock sold first each year to pay that year’s conversion tax, with the capital gains tax on those sales counted

The model also tracked what a basic calculator tends to skip, including California tax every year, the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax, health insurance subsidies for the years before Medicare, and the survivor years with one spouse filing single.

Then I stress tested it, changing one assumption at a time to see which ones moved the answer most.

What did the hypothetical projection show?

In the hypothetical base case, converting cut their projected lifetime income tax, Medicare surcharges and capital gains tax from about $3.3 million to about $1.7 million, and left about $3.4 million more after taxes, in today’s dollars. Their first RMD at 75 dropped from about $121,000 to about $21,000.

The stress tests showed how much that number depends on assumptions. They ran on an earlier version of the model, before we added the company stock sales.

Four things stood out.

  • Converting came out ahead in every test, and the size of the lead ranged roughly tenfold.
  • Return assumptions and the health insurance limit moved the result the most. The base case grew retirement accounts faster than taxable accounts, so any money pushed out of the IRA by RMDs landed somewhere slower. One rate everywhere took most of that away, and the health insurance limit had a similar effect, each cutting the advantage by about $2.6 million.
  • Before Medicare, health insurance subsidies have a cliff, and for 2026 coverage a household earning above 400% of the federal poverty level, about $84,600 for a household of two, loses the entire premium tax credit on marketplace coverage. Staying under that line shrank total conversions from about $1.9 million to about $790,000.
  • Much of the benefit lands later, in the survivor years and for the kids. In the earlier version of the model, if the kids paid no tax on what they inherit, converting would only pull ahead after about 25 years.

The costs are real too. They pay more tax every year through the window, up to about $66,000 more in a single year, and selling the stock gives up the step-up in basis, the reset of a share’s cost to its value at death that heirs would generally receive.

What could change over 30 years?

This plan runs more than 30 years out, and those years are unlikely to follow the model’s assumptions. Three kinds of change matter most.

  • Health, how long each of them lives, a move out of California, spending that rises or falls, or a change in a child’s income or plans can all change the math. A move to a state with no income tax before required withdrawals begin, for example, could shrink the case for converting in California now.
  • The model assumes the same return every year, and real markets never move that way. A rough few years early on change the balances that get converted and taxed. A market drop may also lower the tax cost of converting the same shares, which is one more reason to look at conversions every year.
  • Brackets, Roth rules, inherited IRA rules, the RMD age, Medicare surcharge tiers and California’s own rules can all change, and Congress can rewrite any of them.

One more thing raises the stakes. Since 2018, a Roth conversion can’t be undone, so each year’s conversion locks in that year’s tax.

This is exactly why we don’t do one-time financial planning. Life is constantly changing, so the plan has to be adaptive. Each year, before the December 31 conversion deadline, we size that year’s conversion with their actual income, the market as it stands and the tax law in force, then rerun the projection. Working together through those changes is what makes our partnership so valuable.

Why is paying tax now so hard?

Writing a check to the IRS you could legally put off for more than a decade goes against every instinct. The bill is real and it’s this year. The savings are decades away and they’re estimates. Today’s check tends to feel heavier than a smaller one the kids may never have to write.

So the way we walked through it mattered as much as the math.

  • We started from their goal, so the conversation was about what their kids receive and the tax math served that question.
  • We showed a range, which shows what moves the answer and makes it easier to decide.
  • We reviewed the model with them in person before sending them anything.
  • Each year’s conversion gets sized on its own, so the plan can change when life or tax law does.

Naturally, when you see a big tax bill like that, it’s easy to compare the bigger pre-tax balance you’d keep by not converting with the smaller balance left after paying the tax. The apples-to-apples comparison is after taxes both ways, converting versus not converting. That knee-jerk pull toward the bigger dollar amount can play a little bit of a trick on your mind.

What matters most when deciding whether to convert?

For most families weighing this, a handful of questions decide the answer.

  • Start with what the money is for, since your own spending, a surviving spouse and the kids each point to a different plan.
  • Compare your tax rate now with your rate later, including the survivor years and your heirs’ likely rate, since those are where large pre-tax balances tend to cost the most.
  • Count the low-income years you have before 75, since that window sets how much you can convert at lower rates.
  • Know where the cliffs are, since health insurance subsidies before 65 and Medicare surcharges after can make one extra dollar of income expensive.
  • Paying the tax from a taxable account keeps the full conversion growing inside the Roth, and stock you’d like to sell anyway can do that job.
  • Ask which assumptions carry the result, ask for a range and ask what moves it.

The most important piece here is to think long term. When a lot of people optimize one tax year at a time, trying to keep the most money each year, they can miss the Roth conversion window completely, or never set up a Roth 401(k) in the first place, even as high earners who didn’t qualify for a Roth IRA. The strategy should be thought about well in advance, because the low-tax years between retirement and required withdrawals are limited, and if you don’t plan for them, you can lose that window.

How does a Roth plan tie into the estate plan?

The Roth plan and the estate plan answer the same question, which is what reaches the kids, how it gets there and how much tax comes with it. Like many couples we meet, Mark and Elena didn’t yet have their core estate documents in place.

So the estate plan belongs right next to the Roth plan, and the two shape each other.

  • IRAs and Roth IRAs pass by the beneficiary form on file, outside the will. Getting those forms right matters as much as any conversion.
  • Roth money, taxable accounts with a step-up in basis and pre-tax money each land differently on an heir, so the plan can match each account to the person it fits best.
  • A trust only works for what’s actually titled to it, so retitling accounts and updating beneficiaries is the last step of the estate plan.

At Up Capital we quarterback estate planning inside the client relationship, so the documents, the account titles and the tax plan are built to work together.

How can a plan like this move the Wealth Score?

The Wealth Score measures how well your financial life is designed and whether your money is serving it, across four dimensions, Structure, Experience, Core and Impact. A Roth plan like this one touches two of them most directly.

  • Structure covers how the pieces fit, including how you’ll take cash in retirement, in what order, and how accounts are titled and who inherits them. A year-by-year conversion plan, a clear plan for the company stock and updated beneficiaries all speak to it.
  • Impact covers what the money is for. Mark and Elena’s goal for their kids and the causes they care about drove every choice in the plan, which is the kind of design this dimension looks for.

The score is built to be retaken, so a plan like this gives you something concrete to measure against the next time.

Who might a plan like this fit?

This approach tends to fit people who have most of their savings in pre-tax accounts, several low-income years before 75, taxable money to pay the tax, and a spouse or kids they want to protect from higher taxes later.

It tends to fit less well for people who need their IRA money soon to live on, expect a lower tax rate later, plan to move to a state with no income tax before RMDs begin, or would have to drain their cash reserves to pay the tax.

For some households the right amount to convert is zero. An article can’t tell you which group you’re in. That depends on your income each year, your accounts and what you want the money to do.

What’s the next step?

Before any tax plan, decide what you want the money to do, for you, for the spouse who may outlive you and for whoever comes after. That answer decides which tax plan is worth the cost.

Conversions for 2026 have to be done by December 31. If you want this year in your plan, take the Wealth Score this month, and we’ll look at your accounts, income and goals together.

This article reflects the opinions of Nyle Bayer as of its publication date, and they may change. It is adapted from a real financial planning analysis, with names and personal details changed and generalized so no client can be identified, and figures rounded.

All results shown are hypothetical projections, not actual results, and no actual portfolio or client achieved them. They rely on assumed rates of return, including 8% a year in retirement accounts and 6.28% in taxable accounts in the base case, 2.5% inflation, a 30% tax rate for heirs on inherited pre-tax money and current federal and California tax law. Actual returns, tax law and personal circumstances will differ, and results could be better or worse than shown, possibly by a wide margin. Forward-looking statements involve risk and uncertainty.

This content is for general education only and isn’t individualized investment, tax or legal advice. Review any Roth conversion with a qualified tax professional before making it. Tax figures come from government and third-party sources believed reliable but not guaranteed. Up Capital Management is registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) as an investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training.

Sources

  1. 2026 federal tax brackets, IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32, per the IRS announcement and the Tax Foundation table
  2. 2026 Medicare surcharge (IRMAA) tiers, CMS 2026 Medicare Parts A and B fact sheet
  3. 400% of the federal poverty level for 2026 coverage, Georgia Access state marketplace
  4. Enhanced premium tax credits expiring after 2025, Oregon Health Insurance Marketplace and KFF
  5. Roth conversions made in 2018 or later can’t be recharacterized, IRS FAQs on recharacterization
  6. RMD start age and Roth IRA rules, IRS Retirement Plan and IRA RMD FAQs
  7. Inherited IRA 10-year rule, IRS Retirement Topics, Beneficiary
  8. Projections, Up Capital Management Roth conversion analysis, October 2026

This material is provided by Up Capital Management for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. Past performance is not indicative of future results.

Related Insights

View Nyle's profile →

Have questions about your plan?

The first conversation is short, no obligation, and oriented toward fit.

Schedule a Conversation